My issue with this policy is that there are ZERO repercussions for the officials. Who is policing them to make sure they are making the correct calls? Or if they are abusing this policy?
I think you are sorta missing the point. It doesn't matter if the official makes the wrong call or misses a call. You live with it. You accept the fact that it happens and move on.
You are also dead wrong about no repercussions for officials. I know for a fact that ice hockey officials in the Del Val area lose game assignments and are left off assignors lists because of poor performance or bad behavior.
This isn't exclusive to hockey. All sports have reffing issues. Honestly, I think 95% of them do a good job. Of course there are blown calls, hell we see them every night in pro games, but I think these guys are trying to do their best. The other 5% are either there just for the paycheck or just aren't good. As the previous poster said, the bad ones do start losing assignments, unfortunately, there just aren't enough out there so these guys will still continue to get jobs.
I commend these people for doing it. Sure, they are getting $50-60/game, but to deal with coaches and parents, I'd rather deliver pizza for extra cash.
I was talking to a soccer ref recently. He said he will only do school games because since most are right after school, there's less parents there. Club games on the weekend are packed with parents and doesn't feel like hearing their shit anymore.