A lot of this discussion is a good reminder that the "grass isn't always greener" and more often than not its much worse.
Although, PHC seems to take the brunt of this, nearly every team that offers T1 and T2 does exactly the same thing. They recruit from outside their club first to bring in more players and its incredibly hard to be promoted within from AA to AAA. Why - although T1 costs more than T2, the value of bringing in a new kid to a club is 100% incremental to the P&L, promoting an internal kid is only 50% incremental at best so to be promoted requires you to be significantly better than the current roster which is difficult.
Its much easier to go somewhere else for a year and then come back as now you are 100% incremental $$$ to your former club. I've seen it many times - kid is a strong AA player that deserves AAA shot, but gets cut at AAA tryouts multiple years in a row with same club, he/she goes and plays AAA somewhere else for a year and then tryouts at former club and miraculously they are now good enough for AAA!
Lets all be honest with ourselves, the primary goal of every club is to bring in more money vs the prior year, talent is important but a distant second priority. Its a business and you grow your business through volume at tryouts and if you don't make AAA, they offer you AA.
My advice (many will disagree), go to the CLUB that bests fits your player and family - if that means AAA, AA, or lower great, but the club you play for is most important. Also, don't burn bridges, if you leave for another club, do it in a positive way (even if it wasn't a positive experience) as you never know what the next season will bring.