Comparing the average MHR rating of the AYHL teams (including PHC) to the average MHR rating of the teams that played at the THF Parity Event:
At 2012, the AYHL appears to be much stronger, top to bottom.
At 2011, the AYHL appears to be stronger at the top, but only at the top.
At 2010, the leagues appear to be very comparable.
At 2009, the THF/USPHL appears to be very comparable to the AYHL American, but the AYHL National appears to be stronger.
At 2008, the THF/USHPL appears to be stronger than the AYHL American, but not as strong as the AYHL National.
At 2007, it appears the THF/USPHL teams would struggle to compete in the AHYL American, much less the AYHL National.
But keep in mind that the lowest team or teams in the THF/USPHL might get booted, and several stronger teams might have missed the parity event because they didn't have enough players to travel in April, especially at the older age levels.
With that said, it would appear that the THF/USPHL, in general, is on par, at least for now, with the AYHL American level of play.